Indoor or Outdoor Recess?
When the weather outside is frightful school recess on the playground may not be delightful. Just ask any playground supervisor.
Outdoor recess however, is a reality and daily decisions about “how cold is too cold” is something site principals, teachers and day care directors will be making during the winter months. Snow, wind and icy conditions make deciding when to let kids go out and play a difficult decision.
Video from Active Kids Club
Administrators make the call.
According to the Department of Education, there isn’t a national standard for keeping kids indoors for school recess. Consequently site principals often make this decision based on local situations.
In Southern CA where I worked at a principal, cold is rarely, (if ever) an issue. Generally, students could go outside nearly every day except for when it rains. But in Northern California at Tahoe Truckee Unified School District, they face snow storms and icy conditions frequently like many other mountain areas across the nation. So a temperature standard would not make sense for both these areas even though they are within the same state.
Principals generally take into account precipitation, wind chill and other weather conditions in making an indoor/outdoor decision. Tim Mc Avoy of Utica Community Schools in Michigan put it best, “the bottom line is student safety. It’s not a decision that you can paint with a broad brush.”
When making the decision to go outside for recess school officials need to consider many factors and one of the most influential is the wind chill factor that drives many decisions. Temperature is another factor that in some cases generates an end to the discussion because in some places when the thermometer hits a certain number there is a district policy that takes over. This is typically affected by local weather conditions. For example, in Southern CA children typically do not bring gloves, layered clothing, hats etc to school to wear at recess. A cold day below 50 would probably generate a long hard look at “sending children outdoors” basically because the temperature rarely drops that low and because children do not come to schools with warm snow type coats and hats.
On the other hand, in MN many schools report sending children out doors until the temperature reaches 32 degrees because parents send children expecting them to go outside at recess and dress kids warmly in the winter. Minnesota children generally arrive at school prepared for cold weather and most dress appropriately.
Tips for teachers to beat the cold and keep kids safe.
- Plan outdoor time for the warmest part of the day. You may decide to skip morning recess but add in an afternoon one as the temperature warms up.
- Have students dress in layers. For example, ask parents to send students in heavy coat for the morning with a windbreaker underneath.
- In cold climates you may want to leave open the option for parents to leave a pair of gloves and hat at school “just in case” they might be needed.
- Shorten actual time outdoors recess. Because it takes a long time for students to get on coats, hats, gloves to go outside for recess many teachers find that shortening outdoor recess time on really cold days is appropriate.
How to tell when a child is too cold and at risk for hypothermia
- Shivering is a definite warning sign
- Unusually clumsy play
- Later (stiff and jerky limb movements)
- Bluish cold extremities
- Slurred speech
- Frostbite or severe warning signs and serious symptoms
- Skin color looks white or gray
- Burning sensation in fingers and toes
If you expect frostbite call 911 and wrap child in a warm blanket and give child something warm to drink.
A way to avoid hypothermia is to bundle up, layer clothing, and dress child in a long sleeve shirt with sweatshirt or lightweight jacket. On especially cold days when it is likely students will go out to recess, it is wise to send warm gloves, extra socks, outer layer jacket or coat type windbreaker and wet-resistant clothing.
School Recess Expectations
Another challenge administrators face in regard to weather is the ever-growing concern from parents that children get enough exercise and a break from academics. Parents may look to recess and P.E. as opportunities for students to be active. Some parents have gone as far as to start online petitions called, “Promoting outdoor recess;” and another petition stated, “Montgomery County Public School Parents support outdoor recess in the cold.”
Teachers, on the other hand, may have a different opinion about going out to supervise recess on a cold day, as voiced in a teacher forum. “We are very careful with the kids where I work, as far as making sure that they are not out too long and if someone is really cold for some reason, we all go in. I HATE going outside for duty. It is boring to me and the time goes by so slow. I dress very warm and am not worried about my HAIR either. I wear a warm stocking hat and when I get inside, I look as lovely as the kids with my hat hair and we all have a good laugh.”
Dr. Tony Pangan, pediatrician at Loyola University School of Medicine, points out that kids love to be outside but they are more vulnerable to cold weather than adults. She points out that winter is a great time to get outside and have fun. But she warns, “Children are not small adults.” They have fewer energy reserves than adults. Children respond differently to the elements than adults so extra care in preparing, with the proper clothing and accessories, is a must for safe play on cold days at recess.
* Note: hypothermia happens when the body’s heat loss exceeds the body’s heat production. With mild hypothermia, the body’s core temperature drops from a healthy 37 degrees C. to 32-35 C. Rice, Doyle. Too cold for recess? School Policies vary as much as temps, USA TODAY  Sports Medicine: Playing in the cold? Bundle up, with lots of layers
The Recess Advocacy Toolkit includes: parent letters, a powerpoint presentation, a meeting agenda, and advocacy guide for Saving School Recess. It can be download here : http://www.peacefulplaygrounds.com/right-to-recess-campaign/
Keeping Cool at School: When is it too hot for recess?